Namespaces Card Rulings Discussion. Views Read View source View history. Navigation Yugipedia Mobile site Help Random page. This page was last edited on 17 May , at Since it states it "negates all other card effects on the field" I'm not sure if that covers said lingering effects too. If it said something like "negate the effects of all other cards on the field" instead then I would find it more clear.
Lingering Effects cannot be negated only already applied, so it wouldn't do that. I'm sure there are some weird exceptions, but in your example I am confident that it would not negate it. Well, that's still an assumption. Is there a way to confirm?
Perhaps another case, ruling, etc. The only other card I found with such effect is Gravekeeper's Heretic. Anybody knows what happens to him if you use, let's say, Rush Recklessly on it and activate Necrovalley afterwards? Image proxies on the Konami blog do not reflect cards that exist, and they are subject to change at any time.
Judges do not answer questions on unreleased cards, nor should they answer questions on hypothetical cards or scenarios. Hypothetical in this context meaning cannot be reproduced in the actual game. The effect of Galaxy Queen's Light isn't on the field when Scripture resolves; it has long resolved. Are you familiar with how they work regarding cards later having their effects negated or becoming unaffected by card effects?
It's just that the wording of Scripture and Heretic of "negates all other card effects on the field", as opposed to, let's say, "negate the effects of all other cards on the field" made me wonder if it is more unique since, in a way, a lingering effect could be seen as a card effect left on the field. Not exactly the same case, but IIRC Lose 1 Turn had to be erratad because of a conflict like this: it was negating the effects of monsters that were Special Summoned, but not on the field anymore.
I'm just gonna assume somebody is asking about certain interactions because even if they card is not released in cardboard it sure is being played online. If it's possible to help them with an interaction they had at the time, regardless if it's going to work the same once the card is out I'm going to answer the question lol. As a judge I always thought that line of thought is retarded, because it is.
If the card text changes then so does my ruling. It now clearly works like Skill Drain. Veiler negates the monster's effects on the field. If the monster activates its effect on the field, but leaves the field before the effect resolves, the effect still gets negated because the effect is on the field. Decree negates Trap effects on the field. If a Trap Card activates its effect on the field, but leaves the field before the effect resolves, the effect still gets negated because the effect is on the field.
Skill Drain negates the effects of monsters while those monsters are face-up on the field. If a monster activates its effect on the field, and leaves the field before the effect resolves, the effect doesn't get negated because the monster isn't face-up on the field. There is no such thing as a "lingering effect". This is a non-issue when you should be teaching mechanics rather than specific card interactions in the first place.
Every hypothetical scenario that you can draw a correct conclusion from has associated mechanics that can be taught so that a player can come to the same conclusion on their own and use that knowledge to solve other similar interactions. You should be familiar with how often a player asks a question about a scenario, for you to tell them the answer, and for them to come back minutes later to ask you about the same scenario, only with different cards?
Posted September 10, Can I play this card from my hand to use it's effect? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites. Create an account or sign in to comment You need to be a member in order to leave a comment Create an account Sign up for a new account in our community. Register a new account. Sign in Already have an account? Sign In Now. Szukaj karty:. Card Trivia. This card is among the few cards that activate their effect by their destruction.
0コメント